The comparison between: Magento vs Demandware vs Hybris
I think that when choosing a path ahead, your selection criteria should be considered very much to the question: "Which model best suits my business and my use case"? When that question is answered, you will be in a position to compare Apple.
Magento represents the open source community software movement. Widely accepted mainly in small and medium businesses B2C Magento can be a quick and inexpensive way to stand up to a retailer and you can do whatever you want with this toolkit. because of all open source utilities.
The bottom of Magento is that it is not designed congenially for complex B2B pricing, and Magento scaling can be a challenge if your initial deployment is not well designed. The main complaint about Magento is that because it is open source, support can be a special challenge if you make use of the available utilities. Over time what you end up with is a very customizable one that is quite expensive to maintain. Remember that Magento is a three-tier architecture and to keep the lights on you need expert staffing for database components, web-servers, and applications. Finally, there is no real upgrade path for Magento because of the nature of open source. "Upgrade"
Really is a partial proposal because the different components are improving over time.
So you will suck on Magento's side if you are a small and medium B2C entity with a strong technical staff in-house. Although there are other open source candidates, Magento is still widely used.
DemandWare is probably the most widely used B2C SaaS e-commerce platform for installation bases. The majority of DemandWare customers are B2C retailers, although DemandWare has pushed the Omni-Channel. The main advantage of using DemandWare is that it's very simple to support regarding traditional 3-tier solutions such as Magento and Hybris. In addition, DemandWare solutions can be implemented in a shorter time frame because many of the infrastructure constraints present in traditional models are abstracted in their SaaS environment.
I will need to digest for a moment to talk about the "Cloud," one of the most abusive terms in our industry. Many legacy vendors claim to have a simple cloud solution that offers archived versions of their three-tier solutions. These stored systems still require the same amount of expertise and the need to manage. The only difference is that your infrastructure is outsourced and these systems are theoretically (but not always in practice) more scalable. For situations where throwing more hardware than the answer to that scaling is true, there are often architectural problems when playing. Emptor caveat.
I'm not aware of any really bold competition for DemandWare for B2C retailers, but our CloudCraze product compares favorably in B2B (Full Disclosure: Author as CEO of CloudCraze).
DemandWare is built for retail and the result is not ideal for complex use cases and B2B pricing. In addition, the DemandWare revenue sharing model is more suited to B2C than B2B. I do not understand the leading transaction rates supported on DemandWare, but it's clear that for agile, agile B2C operations, small to medium-sized DemandWare retailers can be a solid choice. Especially if there is a shortage of technical resources available to administer the site.
I'm sure I would disturb the Hybris loyalists out there with my generosity, but here.
Hybris is best suited for large-scale multi-channel operations in place. The success they have at companies like WW Grainger is a strong testament to this. This product is capable of handling most of the large-scale eCommerce business use cases that I have seen. By that time, I would consider Hybris the best "Java stack" solution ever.
However, the challenge with Hybris is the time and cost needed to deploy and maintain their solution. At its core, Hybris's architecture is based on technology models that were originated in the early 2000s, more than a decade ago. The consequence of this is that very rarely see a Hybris deployment under $ 3 million, all in. Most deployments I have seen are north of $ 5million in cost. Also, be ready to have a huge technical team (minimum 5-10 resources) to maintain your performance.
Deployment Hybris not fast. Mostly I have heard of it
 |
| Magento vs Demandware vs Hybris |
MAGENTO
Magento represents the open source community software movement. Widely accepted mainly in small and medium businesses B2C Magento can be a quick and inexpensive way to stand up to a retailer and you can do whatever you want with this toolkit. because of all open source utilities.
The bottom of Magento is that it is not designed congenially for complex B2B pricing, and Magento scaling can be a challenge if your initial deployment is not well designed. The main complaint about Magento is that because it is open source, support can be a special challenge if you make use of the available utilities. Over time what you end up with is a very customizable one that is quite expensive to maintain. Remember that Magento is a three-tier architecture and to keep the lights on you need expert staffing for database components, web-servers, and applications. Finally, there is no real upgrade path for Magento because of the nature of open source. "Upgrade"
Really is a partial proposal because the different components are improving over time.
So you will suck on Magento's side if you are a small and medium B2C entity with a strong technical staff in-house. Although there are other open source candidates, Magento is still widely used.
Related post: Magento vs Demandware
DEMANDWARE
DemandWare is probably the most widely used B2C SaaS e-commerce platform for installation bases. The majority of DemandWare customers are B2C retailers, although DemandWare has pushed the Omni-Channel. The main advantage of using DemandWare is that it's very simple to support regarding traditional 3-tier solutions such as Magento and Hybris. In addition, DemandWare solutions can be implemented in a shorter time frame because many of the infrastructure constraints present in traditional models are abstracted in their SaaS environment.
I will need to digest for a moment to talk about the "Cloud," one of the most abusive terms in our industry. Many legacy vendors claim to have a simple cloud solution that offers archived versions of their three-tier solutions. These stored systems still require the same amount of expertise and the need to manage. The only difference is that your infrastructure is outsourced and these systems are theoretically (but not always in practice) more scalable. For situations where throwing more hardware than the answer to that scaling is true, there are often architectural problems when playing. Emptor caveat.
I'm not aware of any really bold competition for DemandWare for B2C retailers, but our CloudCraze product compares favorably in B2B (Full Disclosure: Author as CEO of CloudCraze).
DemandWare is built for retail and the result is not ideal for complex use cases and B2B pricing. In addition, the DemandWare revenue sharing model is more suited to B2C than B2B. I do not understand the leading transaction rates supported on DemandWare, but it's clear that for agile, agile B2C operations, small to medium-sized DemandWare retailers can be a solid choice. Especially if there is a shortage of technical resources available to administer the site.
HYBRIS
I'm sure I would disturb the Hybris loyalists out there with my generosity, but here.
Hybris is best suited for large-scale multi-channel operations in place. The success they have at companies like WW Grainger is a strong testament to this. This product is capable of handling most of the large-scale eCommerce business use cases that I have seen. By that time, I would consider Hybris the best "Java stack" solution ever.
However, the challenge with Hybris is the time and cost needed to deploy and maintain their solution. At its core, Hybris's architecture is based on technology models that were originated in the early 2000s, more than a decade ago. The consequence of this is that very rarely see a Hybris deployment under $ 3 million, all in. Most deployments I have seen are north of $ 5million in cost. Also, be ready to have a huge technical team (minimum 5-10 resources) to maintain your performance.
Deployment Hybris not fast. Mostly I have heard of it
The comparison between: Magento vs Demandware vs Hybris
Reviewed by Anonymous
on
May 01, 2018
Rating:
Reviewed by Anonymous
on
May 01, 2018
Rating:
No comments: